White hat link building
White hat link building is earning links in ways that follow search engines' published rules - above all Google's spam policies - by giving site owners a genuine reason to link. Black hat link building is the opposite: buying, manufacturing or automating links to manipulate rankings.
Also called: white hat backlinks, white hat SEO, black hat link building, black hat SEO, grey hat link building
Published
The labels come from old westerns, where the hero wore a white hat and the villain a black one, and SEO borrowed them to say which side of the search engines' rules a tactic falls on. The rules are written by the search engines, not by the industry, and Google's version is short: link spam is creating links to or from a site primarily to manipulate search rankings.
The practical test is whether the link would exist if search engines did not count links. A journalist citing your research, a resource page listing your tool, a partner linking to your integration: each of those links has a reason to exist for readers, and each is white hat however much effort went into earning it. A link that exists only because someone paid for it to pass ranking credit, or because software placed it, is black hat however natural it looks.
Between the two sits what practitioners call grey hat: tactics that are not obviously spam but sit close to the line, such as paid guest posts presented as editorial, link insertions bought into old articles, or reciprocal links arranged in bulk. Plenty of services sell "white hat links" that are in fact paid placements, and under Google's policies a paid link needs rel="sponsored" whatever the seller calls it.
White hat link building tactics
- Outreach for editorial links. Contacting relevant sites with a specific reason to link - a resource, a correction, an article - and leaving the decision to them.
- Guest posting for an audience. Writing genuinely useful articles for publications your customers read, with links where they help the reader.
- Broken link and resource page building. Pointing editors at dead links on their pages, and at resources that belong on the lists they maintain.
- Reclaiming links and mentions. Fixing broken pages on your site that still carry links, and asking for a link on mentions that lack one.
- Creating something worth citing. Original research, free tools and clear reference pages that people link to because they are useful.
- Digital PR. Giving journalists stories, data and expert comment worth covering.
Black hat link building tactics
Google's spam policies describe these patterns, or the practices behind them, as link spam:
- Buying or selling links that pass ranking credit. Including links exchanged for money, free products or services, unless the link is marked rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow".
- Private blog networks. Sites built or bought only to link to other sites - in the policy's words, low-value content created primarily to manipulate linking and ranking signals.
- Excessive link exchanges. "Link to me and I'll link to you" arrangements, and partner pages that exist only for cross-linking.
- Automated link building. Programs or services that create links in comments, forums, profiles and directories, or publish spun articles with links in them.
- Guest posts and press releases with optimized anchors. Keyword-rich links placed in articles, guest posts or press releases distributed on other sites, which the policy names directly.
- Hidden and widely distributed links. Links buried in widgets and themes, and links spread across the footers or templates of many unrelated sites.
What happens to sites that rely on black hat links
Google says its systems, including the machine-learning spam detection it calls SpamBrain, work to detect link spam and neutralize it, so the usual outcome is that the links stop counting and whatever rankings they were propping up fall away. Where the pattern is serious, Google's reviewers can apply a manual action for unnatural links, reported in Search Console, which stays until the links are removed or disavowed and a reconsideration request is accepted.
The cost is not only the penalty. Money spent on links that are ignored is wasted, and rankings built on them are fragile in a way that is hard to see until an update takes them away.
How to tell which side a tactic is on
- Would the link exist without search engines? If the only reason for it is ranking credit, it is link spam, whatever it is called.
- Did anything of value change hands? Money, products, services or a link in return. If so, the link needs rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow".
- Who decided to place it? An editor exercising judgment about their own page, or you, a vendor or a piece of software?
- Is the anchor text something a person would write? People linking on their own use brand names, titles and plain descriptions, not the same keyword phrase every time.
- For the white hat methods in practice, read how to get backlinks within the rules.
Common questions
Is link building outreach white hat?
Yes. Asking a site to link to you is how most editorial links start, and Google's policies do not object to asking. What matters is what the site gets for saying yes: a better page for its readers is white hat, while payment for a link that passes ranking credit is not, however politely it was requested.
Is guest posting white hat?
Guest posting for an audience is. Google's policies name links with optimized anchor text in guest posts as link spam, and Google has warned that guest posting at scale without qualified links can draw manual action. So the difference is intent and scale: a few useful articles for publications your readers trust is a normal part of publishing, while hundreds of thin articles written to place exact-match links is not.
Can white hat link building be automated?
The research and the email can be; the decision to link cannot. Software that finds relevant sites, drafts outreach and tracks replies still leaves each editor free to say no, so the links it leads to are editorial. Software that places links itself - in comments, profiles or networks of sites - is black hat by Google's definition.